Sleep, Melatonin, and Autism: What makes the Difference?

"Santa won't come if you're not asleep!" I remember whispering urgently to my brother one Christmas Eve, my heart racing as the clock ticked past midnight. There I was, a worried older sister, lying awake and increasingly frustrated as my brother tossed and turned in the next bed. Despite my best efforts at creative threats involving Santa's strict sleeping requirements, sleep just wouldn't come for him. That Christmas turned out fine – Santa was more understanding about sleep difficulties than my eight-year-old self had imagined. But fast forward a few decades, and now, as a psychiatrist specializing in autism, that memory has taken on new meaning. What I didn't understand then but know now is that my brother's struggles with sleep were part of his autism and ADHD – something that affects up to 80% of individuals with these conditions.

Today, I want to share what I've learned about one of our most powerful tools for helping with sleep in autism: melatonin. Often called the "darkness hormone" or "sleep hormone," melatonin is a natural hormone primarily produced by the pineal gland in our brain. But its role in the body is far more complex than many realize. While most of us think of melatonin as our body's natural sleep signal that helps us feel drowsy at bedtime, it plays numerous roles throughout our body.

Melatonin isn't just produced in the brain – it's actively working in multiple systems throughout our body. In the gastrointestinal tract, it helps regulate digestion. Our skin uses it to defend against UV radiation. It's active in our eyes, helping with light adaptation, and in our immune system, providing antioxidant protection. Even our bone marrow and reproductive organs utilize melatonin for various essential functions.

For many autistic individuals, this complex melatonin system works differently. I've observed how these differences significantly impact sleep patterns through my clinical work. Many autistic people produce less melatonin, or their bodies release it at different times than expected. The reason comes down to a specific enzyme in the body (called ASMT) responsible for making melatonin. In autism, this enzyme often works differently, leading to unique sleep patterns.

This widespread distribution of melatonin throughout the body and its multiple functions may help explain why some autistic individuals taking melatonin supplements often experience benefits beyond improved sleep. Understanding these biological differences has transformed how we approach sleep challenges in autism. Rather than viewing unusual sleep patterns as something that needs to be "fixed," we can now better appreciate why many autistic individuals experience sleep differently.

Looking back at that Christmas Eve with my brother, I wish I had understood then what I know now – that his sleep patterns weren't just about willpower or Santa's rules but about fundamental differences in his body's biology. This knowledge has helped me develop more effective, personalized approaches to support better sleep for my patients when needed, moving beyond one-size-fits-all solutions to recognize and work with each individual's unique biological patterns.

Now, let's discuss the practical aspects of using melatonin supplements - including some critical safety considerations that aren't often discussed.

1. Be aware that actual melatonin content can vary significantly from what's listed on the label. Consider researching consumer testing reports before selecting a brand.
2. While melatonin is generally considered safe, research indicates that doses exceeding 10mg may affect blood sugar levels and thyroid function. In my clinical practice, I typically recommend between 1 and 5 mg. I find a particular formulation called biphasic release helpful for patients who tend to wake during the night, while immediate release works well for those who mainly struggle with falling asleep initially.
3. Different age groups need different approaches; sometimes, sleep challenges need additional strategies.

Remember, this information is meant to inform discussions with your doctor, not replace their advice. Every autistic person's sleep needs are unique, and finding the right approach often takes time and careful observation.

Want to explore autism and insomnia more deeply? Join the Autism Roadmaps Community, where we regularly explore crucial mental health topics affecting the autism community, including comprehensive approaches to insomnia. Our members find immense value in our deep-dive discussions, evidence-based resources, and supportive community of practitioners and families.